A1.06. Can Algorithms Care for Territories? Debating the Ethical Uses of AI in Spatial Planning and Urban Design
Site de la conférence : https://ai-geography.sciencesconf.org/771062
Inès Ramirez-Cobo 1, *, @ , Yann Blanchi 2, *, @
1 : Pacte, Laboratoire de sciences sociales
Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Université Grenoble Alpes, Sciences Po Grenoble-UGA – Institut d’études politiques de Grenoble
2 : École nationale supérieure dárchitecture de Grenoble
Université Grenoble Alpes* : Corresponding author
Artificial intelligence (AI) systems are increasingly entering the fields of spatial planning, spatial design, and urbanism. While generative models and algorithmic decision-support systems currently embody the promise of improving the analysis of complex socio-spatial phenomena, predicting territorial dynamics, and generating desirable scenarios, their use also raises fundamental questions for planning thought: What new socio-spatial relationships and dependencies do these technologies induce? How do they reshape the enduring tension between the need to plan the future of inhabited territories and the need to cope with growing political, social, and environmental uncertainties? What vision of the world do they convey? And how does this vision shape projects aimed at transforming the built and natural environment?
These questions resonate with the need for territorial sustainability that characterises contemporary debates on the ethical transformation of spatial planning, design, and the production of territories through the lens of “care” (Fleury & Fenoglio, 2024). Rather than relying on normative models of justice in which “universal values apply to a subject who is both abstract and arbitrarily assumed to be autonomous, that is, without social embeddedness” (Ibos, 2019), approaches to “spatial care” draw attention to concrete situations, conditions of habitability and relational accessibility, as well as interdependencies with the environment (Lussault, 2024). Yet, when territories and their inhabitants are concerned, bringing generative modelling and care ethics together may appear contradictory for several reasons.
First, algorithmic models necessarily operate through abstraction, categorisation, and simplification. In doing so, they risk overlooking precisely the local particularities, everyday experiences, and situated forms of knowledge to which care perspectives invite us to pay attention. Second, algorithmic systems may reproduce social logics of exclusion that can remain invisible to their designers (Ménissier, 2025), thereby amplifying existing inequalities through biased data and modelling choices. This raises important questions of fairness, transparency, accountability, and participation in planning and design processes (Sanchez et al., 2025). Furthermore, these technologies are embedded in an economy of innovation and optimisation grounded in a capitalist logic of value accumulation, within which the ethical dimension may amount to little more than an “alibi” aimed at making such technologies acceptable (Ménissier, 2025, p. 139). Finally, AI technologies rely on extensive material infrastructures and high levels of natural resource consumption, whose environmental and territorial impacts challenge both narratives of an immaterial digital transition (Crawford, 2022; Lopez & Diguet, 2023) and ethical approaches to AI when considered through the principles of care (Nurok, 2024).
Despite the extensive literature highlighting the tensions between AI and spatial care, this call for papers proposes to explore the conditions under which they might be articulated. To this end, it invites contributions to examine the hypothesis that AI could contribute to renewing planning thought and design practices through one or more of the following three complementary hypotheses:
(1) AI as a revealer of territorial vulnerabilities: as a material and territorially embedded technology, its deployment makes visible chains of interdependence, finite resources, critical infrastructures, and, ultimately, human and non-human vulnerabilities (Mytton, 2021);
(2) AI as an operational tool for mediation: capable of clarifying planning issues, identifying complex interdependencies within inhabited spaces, and contributing to their translation and assessment (Azadgar et al., 2026);
(3) AI as a political device: capable of redistributing the capacity to produce spatial proposals, traditionally reserved for experts, and thereby fostering the emergence of democratised forms of expertise among actors usually excluded from decision-making processes (Huang et al., 2026).
Rather than asking whether AI is compatible with care, this session proposes to explore the material, operational, and political conditions under which algorithms might foster caring planning and design practices. We welcome theoretical, empirical, and methodological contributions at the intersection of geography, spatial planning, architecture, urban design, critical data studies, and care studies that investigate what AI does to territories, what it enables us to know about territories, and how it transforms our capacity to act on and with territories.
References
Azadgar, A., Sepe, M., Gańcza, A., Lorens, P., Luciani, G., & Nyka, L. (2026). Integrating AI and spatial analysis for resilient and inclusive 15-minute cities: A case study of Gdańsk. Cities, 173, 107011. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cities.2026.107011
Crawford, K. (2022). Contre-atlas de l’intelligence artificielle. Les coûts politiques et environnementaux de l’IA. Essais.
Fleury, C., & Fenoglio, A. (2024). Éthique et design. Pour un climat de soin. PUF, Paris.
Huang, R., Hou, Y., Bettega, M., Zhang, K., & Zeng, W. (2026). Introducing ManyViews: An AI-assisted tool to support citizens’ engagement in the design of urban spaces. International Journal of Human-Computer Studies, 211, 103796. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhcs.2026.103796
Ibos, C. (2019). Éthiques et politiques du care. Cartographie d’une catégorie critique. Clio. Femmes, Genre, Histoire, 49, 181–219. https://doi.org/10.4000/clio.16440
Lussault, M. (2024). Le care spatial pour un monde vulnérable. In Éthique et Design. Pour un climat de soin (pp. 113–132). Paris.
Lopez, F., & Diguet, C. (2023). Sous le feu numérique. Spatialités et énergies des data centers. MètisPresses, Genève.
Ménissier, T. (2025). Vocabulaire critique de l’intelligence artificielle. Hermann, Paris.
Mytton, D. (2021). Data centre water consumption. npj Clean Water, 4, 11. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41545-021-00101-w
Nurok, V. (2024). Quelle éthique pour les nouvelles technologies ? Nanotechnologies, Cybergénétique, Intelligence Artificielle. VRIN, Paris.
Sanchez, T. W., Brenman, M., & Ye, X. (2025). The ethical concerns of artificial intelligence in urban planning. Journal of the American Planning Association, 91, 294–307. https://doi.org/10.1080/01944363.2024.2355305
Session
Language of text : English
Topics : Territorial and Spatial planning facing AI
Keywords : Planning and Design ; Spatial Care ; Generative Modelling ; Ethical Uses ; Territorial Vulnerabilities
Key Dates
- Call for Papers Opens: November 16th 2026
- Paper Proposal Deadline : January 4th 2027 (Firm deadline)
- Notification of Acceptance: January 25th 2027
- Registration Opens: January 25th 2027
- Conference Begins: 5 July 2027